Is the U.S. Dollar Still a Safe Haven in 2025?

Is the U.S. Dollar Losing Its Safe-Haven Spark? Capital Economics Thinks So

For decades, the U.S. dollar has been the bedrock of global finance a currency investors sprint to in times of trouble. But in 2025, even that time-tested faith is showing cracks.

Capital Economics, a respected voice in macroeconomic strategy, is now cautioning that the dollar's dominant status is looking vulnerable. The culprit? A chaotic mix of tariff threats, policy uncertainty, and investor nerves all driven by President Donald Trump’s unpredictable trade agenda.

Let’s break down what’s happening, and why the dollar may no longer be the unshakable safe haven it once was.

A Dollar Under Pressure

Earlier this April, the U.S. dollar index which tracks the greenback against a basket of major global currencies slid to near three-year lows. That’s a notable red flag.

Why? Typically, in times of global market jitters, the dollar gets stronger. Investors treat it like a financial bunker safe, reliable, and backed by U.S. economic power. But this time, it’s the opposite. The dollar has slumped, while rival currencies like the euro and Japanese yen gained ground.

According to Capital Economics, the ongoing turmoil sparked by Trump’s abrupt tariff policies has dented market confidence in both U.S. assets and institutions.

What Sparked This Shift?

The warning signs began flashing on April 2, 2025, when President Trump announced sweeping reciprocal tariffs targeting several countries across multiple sectors. The markets reacted instantly volatility spiked in both equities and bonds. Shortly after, the administration reversed course, delaying some tariffs and offering exemptions for consumer electronics like smartphones and laptops.

Still, the damage was already done.

Investors began retreating from dollar-backed positions. U.S. Treasury bonds, which are usually seen as rock-solid assets, also faced a sell-off. According to Capital Economics, this "dislocation" in the bond market is not just about price shifts it signals deeper distrust in America’s economic stability.

From Confidence to Caution

In a recent note to clients, Capital Economics didn’t mince words. They argue that the “indirect damage” from these tariff shocks has introduced a new layer of uncertainty into global markets. This goes beyond short-term pricing it touches on long-term faith in U.S. institutions, a core reason why the dollar has remained dominant for so long.

While the analysts stopped short of saying the dollar will be dethroned anytime soon, they acknowledged that its reserve currency status which allows the U.S. to borrow cheaply and maintain influence is now, for the first time in decades, "somewhat in question."

What’s at Stake?

If the dollar's safe-haven image continues to fade, there could be ripple effects:

• Foreign central banks may begin diversifying their reserves into other currencies, like the euro or Chinese yuan.
• U.S. debt could become more expensive to finance.
• Global trade contracts, which rely heavily on dollar pricing, may slowly shift toward alternatives.
   

It’s worth noting that the dollar has faced challengers before from the eurozone in the early 2000s to China’s growing economic clout but none have fully replaced it. The key difference now? The threat may be coming from within the U.S., driven by erratic policies and fading institutional trust.

A Momentary Dip or a Turning Point?

Despite this gloomy analysis, Capital Economics still sees a potential path to recovery. They believe that “inertia and network effects” will keep the dollar afloat at least in the near future.

Currencies, after all, are about trust and habit. The dollar remains deeply embedded in international trade, banking systems, and financial infrastructure. Replacing it isn’t easy.

Still, the analysts sound a clear warning: if current trends continue, the world may start seriously questioning the dollar’s future role.

Will the Dollar Bounce Back?

Capital Economics typically expects the dollar index to revert to standard trading ranges after sudden drops. But not this time.

"Given the current circumstances," they wrote, "we have less confidence in that pattern holding up." In other words, the dollar might stay weak longer than usual, depending on how U.S. policies evolve.

This means the dollar’s next move could be shaped more by political decisions than economic fundamentals especially if more tariff U-turns or institutional shakeups occur.

In Context: Is the Dollar’s Status Really in Jeopardy?

While it's tempting to declare the dollar’s decline, a longer-term view offers perspective. The greenback still accounts for around 58% of global forex reserves (as per IMF data) and is used in nearly 90% of forex trades. Those numbers don’t shift overnight.

However, if enough tremors hit the system like fiscal instability, political interference at the Fed, or unpredictable global policy the world might begin to hedge its bets.

Other assets like gold, Bitcoin, and Swiss francs are already seeing safe-haven inflows during this volatility, indicating a cautious shift in investor behavior.

Final Thoughts

The U.S. dollar isn’t dead but it’s definitely under pressure.

Tariff-driven uncertainty and declining faith in U.S. governance are testing the dollar’s once-untouchable position as the world’s go-to safe haven. While inertia may keep it dominant for now, cracks are showing.

If there’s a lesson in this, it’s that global financial leadership depends on more than just size it requires trust, consistency, and clarity. If those falter, even the world’s strongest currencies can wobble.

Got a hot finance tip or insider scoop? Share it with our editorial team at [email protected] – we’d love to hear from you.